From: entekhab.ir
Subject: پاسخ آیت الله سبحانی به شبهه وهابیون در مورد توسل به پیامبر اکرم
Date: Mon, 25 May 2026 16:31:07 +0330
MIME-Version: 1.0
Content-Type: multipart/related;
	boundary="--5396C63DFFC156B00B2AC50DC9FE6CD5_MULTIPART_MIXED";
	type="text/html"
X-MimeOLE: Produced By IRANSAMANEH.COM

This is a multi-part message in MIME format.

----5396C63DFFC156B00B2AC50DC9FE6CD5_MULTIPART_MIXED
Content-Type: text/html
Content-Transfer-Encoding: base64
Content-Location: http://mhtfile/index.html
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----5396C63DFFC156B00B2AC50DC9FE6CD5_MULTIPART_MIXED
Content-Type: image/vnd.microsoft.icon
Content-Transfer-Encoding: base64
Content-Location: http://mhtfile/favicon.ico
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----5396C63DFFC156B00B2AC50DC9FE6CD5_MULTIPART_MIXED--